Free Shipping on U.S. orders of $80+
Returns up to 365 Days

Captain's Choice

Captain's Choice is a brand that got started in the quest of the perfect aftershave. After smelling everything on the self at the local store, he set out to make his own. The owner is passionate about finding not only a great base for his products, but making sure it does the job it's supposed to do. So, his aftershaves close the pores and provide needed moisture, and his soaps clean well and smell great. The feedback and desires of customers is carefully considered when the final touches are made on these products. Just check out those customer reviews. We share his enthusiasm for all things that smell lovely and have even had the privilege of working along side of the Captain on a new product release: North. In pursuit of perfect, North went through dozens of revisions and review from two focus groups. Good enough, wasn't. It had to be great. His nautical labeling and packaging is brilliant and worthy of any fine shop or boutique (like ours). Our hats are off to The Captain!

Captain's Choice Aftershave
Captain's Choice Shaving Soap
Products 1-12 of 16
Captain's Choice Reviews
Exactly What You Would Expect
Captain's Choice Shaving Soap, 45th Parallel "First of all, the scent is AMAZING, it reminds me of black cherry yogurt. As a newer wet shaver, who doesn't even have a year of wet shaving under his belt, this soap is definitely up to my standards. It has a great scent, lather, slickness, and keeps your skin hydrated after the shave. There really isn't much I have to argue against this, even though I'm relatively inexperienced, I know that my shaving experience was completely satisfying with this product. I've had a fair share of shaving soaps, since I usually order the sample packs and this was absolutely in my top 3 choices. Definitely recommend to anyone who loves a fruity scent and wants a shaving soap that performs great.
Great product for the money.
Captain's Choice Lime Aftershave "Great product for the money.
Captains Choice North Aftershave
Captain's Choice North Aftershave I've been using witch hazel for over 20 years. This was a nice change, it has an initial burn that was pretty mild, a hint of clove that is not overpowering. The smell does not last very long which was kind on nice. Recommended
Captain's Choice Shaving Soap, Bay Rum This stuff is great! Thick, rich lather! Strongly recommend.
this is the best
Captain's Choice Sandalwood Shave BalmI have used the other balm and this one is for the aftershave comfort
Great Stuff!
Captain's Choice Shave Balm Sample 4-pack.I got a sample pack of Captain's Choice after shave balms as a promotional item that came with my order. I really like it, especially the 'North' scent. It's kinda like a better version of bay rum. It leaves my skin feeling smooth and soft and the scent is just the right strength. It fades like it should so I don't have a strong smell at work. I have avoided this brand because to me the name conjures up a novelty, pirate image and I tend to favor the English products with their more traditional and established brand names. But from now on Captain's Choice will be among my favorites and I will be trying out their other products.
The balm is the bomb!
Captain's Choice Shave Balm Sample 4-pack.Excellent after shave balm that cools your face, while moisturizing and hydrating.
Best so far
Captain's Choice Cat O' Nine Tails Aftershave.I have extremely sensitive skin on my neck and have at least mild irritation no matter what cream or soap I use. However, this stuff is the best I've tried for knocking down the irritation and keeping things comfortable. I think it smells great and I love the sensation, but most of all, just love the effectiveness. Truly a great product.
Number of questions: 0