Free Shipping on U.S. orders of $80+
Returns up to 365 Days

The New York Shaving Company

At the heart of this company is a love story. John Scala who founded The New York Shaving company sold his wife's engagement ring (legitimately -- with her permission) to follow his dreams of reintroducing the old-fashioned way of shaving and providing men with a world class shave using only the finest ingredients. With several unique scents available you will surely get the close, smooth shave you have been looking for and feel confident that you you are putting the highest quality all natural ingredients on your face.

The New York Shaving Company Shave Cream & Soap
Products 1-12 of 18
The New York Shaving Company Reviews
Great sample pack
All samples provide a thick slippery lather. Each sample, except unscented, has a pleasant subtle scent. My favorite was the Old St. Patrick's.
An amazing cream
Has a great lather and goes on smooth. No irritation and has a great scent. One of my favorites.
Good lather, Some Sting
The New York Shaving Company Tonsorial Shave Cream, 4 oz "Built a good lather, but on first use, there was some unexpected sting. I didn't suffer any rash or other lasting skin irritation, so it will go into my rotation, but if the stinging sensation continues on each shave, I will not reorder.
The New York Shaving Company Old St. Patrick's Shave Cream, 4 oz "great lather and protection and very alluring scent. I've never smelled anything quite like it and i've tried a lot of creams and soaps. highly recommended product.
Great Cream!
The New York Shaving Company Elizabeth Shave Cream, 4 oz "This cream provided great cushion and the best slickness I have experienced from any cream I've tried. I also find the scent to be very pleasant during the shave. I am very happy with this purchase.
Sample pack
The New York Shaving Company Shaving Cream Sample Pack "Good products, very nice all sample
Nice size good value spreads
The New York Shaving Company Pre Shave Oil, 2 oz Nice size good value spreads nice on the face goes a long way
The New York Shaving Company Elizabeth Shave Cream, 4 oz I discovered The New York Shaving Co by purchasing the sampler pack of shave creams, and was very pleased with the results. All of the scents they produce are excellent, but the Elizabeth Street scent struck me as very original, I have not smelled another scent that really comes close to it. It has since been in my permanent rotation. Other than scent, it also gave a very smooth and soothing shave. My skin feels great afterwards and the scent will last for a few hours, but is not over powering. I definitely recommend trying Elizabeth Street out, you won't be disappointed!
Number of questions: 0