Free Shipping on U.S. orders of $50+
Returns up to 365 Days

Captain's Choice

Captain's Choice is a brand that got started in the quest of the perfect aftershave. After smelling everything on the self at the local store, he set out to make his own. The owner is passionate about finding not only a great base for his products, but making sure it does the job it's supposed to do. So, his aftershaves close the pores and provide needed moisture, and his soaps clean well and smell great. The feedback and desires of customers is carefully considered when the final touches are made on these products. Just check out those customer reviews. We share his enthusiasm for all things that smell lovely and have even had the privilege of working along side of the Captain on a new product release: North. In pursuit of perfect, North went through dozens of revisions and review from two focus groups. Good enough, wasn't. It had to be great. His nautical labeling and packaging is brilliant and worthy of any fine shop or boutique (like ours). Our hats are off to The Captain!

Captain's Choice Aftershave
Captain's Choice Shaving Soap
Products 1-12 of 22
Captain's Choice Reviews
Love it
Catie's Bubbles Shaving Soap, Connecticut Shade Great soap will definitely buy again
A really good sandalwood scent
Captain's Choice Sandalwood Aftershave A real nice sandalwood scent, not my all-time favorite version of sandalwood, but probably in my top 5.
Captains Choice North
Captain's Choice North Shave Balm So far so good. Scent is there but is light which is ok. The balm is not heavy and soothes my face after a close shave. Using it for the colder months for more protection than (and less alcohol than) an after shave splash. Purchased a couple of after shave balms and will report on and compare them over the next several months. However, I would purchase again.
Nice Addition
Captain's Choice Shaving Soap, Sandalwood Found this soap was a tad slow to lather up the first couple of shaves. Then on the 3rd shave it seemed to lather uo real well using an old boar brush that was at one time made availabke to members of the Badger and the Blade.Razor used was a futur clone. Scent is awesome and lasts a pretty good amount of time.The glide was smooth and left me with an awesome bbs shave on 3 passes.Add moisture to this soap slowly.When I bought the soap I also bought the aftershave in the same awesome scent
Not quite what I expected ...
Captain's Choice Bay Rum Aftershave ... but I really like it. Great service from WCG, and I will order more after shaves.
Captain's Choice Sandalwood Balm.
Captain's Choice Sandalwood Shave Balm I've used this for a couple weeks and I'm very satisfied. The scent is not overpowering and last a while. I have oily skin and this does not exaggerate that issue. If I have any razor burn, the balm really helps and my neck does not feel irritated.
Smooth and bracing
Captain's Choice Bay Rum Aftershave Nice aftershave with interesting scent Subtle Clive, tobacco, herbal. Very nice. Scent is fun when you use the product , but not so strong that it stays with you all day. Very cool and bracing! And bottle includes a restricted insert at the opening, so you don't have to worry about spilling or using to much.
Nice Clean Aroma
Captain's Choice Cat O' Nine Tails Aftershave A very nice Bay style aftershave. Has a nice burn to it that is not overpowering, more of a warming sensation. I had received a free sample from WCS a while back and liked it, so bought a bottle and like it too. Fragrance lasts for a decent time as well. Its a little different twist on your normal bay with little to no clove smell, but does the trick!
Number of questions: 0