Skip to content
Free Mystery Gift + Free Shipping On Orders $50 +. Use Code FREEGIFT
Free Mystery Gift + Free Shipping On Orders $50 +. Use Code FREEGIFT

Captain's Choice Bay Rum Aftershave

64 reviews
$18.95
THIS ITEM SHIPS FREE ON ORDERS $45+
SKU AS-CAP-001
  • Classic aftershave from Captain's Choice
  • Alcohol splash with witch hazel & glycerin for soothing and moisturizing
  • Scented with a Bay Rum aroma that has people talking

This Chicago area company has taken the shaving world by storm with this Bay Rum aftershave. The Captain was inspired to create his own aftershave when nothing on the market met his needs. In 2011 after months of development, he released this Captain's Choice Bay Rum Aftershave to rave reviews.

Captain's Choice Aftershave is the Bay Rum that has changed the mind of many a hater. It is a full-bodied bay rum with hints of cinnamon and citrus. For those of you who find the cloves overbearing in many bay rums, this is the bay rum for you! Not only does it smell great, it is also a very nice post shave treatment that will keep you feeling fresh and moisturized all day. This is a traditional alcohol splash (with a wake-you-up-in-the-morning warmth), but the witch hazel and glycerin keep it from being drying. The natural ingredients may settle over time, so give it a good shake before use.

It is packaged in an amber bottle with a classy nautical label. Under the screw top lid is a dispenser insert to make sure that your splash isn't a flood. One reviewer said, "After applying this [aftershave], I notice that the looks from passengers on the subway. They tend to give me smiles and even at times sensuous gazes. I wonder, is it all in my head or in that bottle I used after shaving this morning?" Get yours today and find out!

Size: 4oz

Ingredients: alcohol, witch hazel, essential oils and extracts, glycerin

Made in the USA

SHIPPING RESTRICTIONS: This product contains alcohol, which is potentially hazardous for shipping. We cannot ship it outside of the continental USA. If you are an international customer, this item will be refunded and will not be shipped. If you are a customer in the continental USA, your order will ship via ground regardless of the delivery option selected.

Customer Reviews
4.3 Based on 64 Reviews
Write a Review Ask a Question
  • Reviews
  • Questions

Thank you for submitting a review!

Your input is very much appreciated. Share it with your friends so they can enjoy it too!

Filter Reviews:
  • favorite
  • scent
  • bay rum
  • splash
  • room
  • uses
  • boys
  • perfume
CB
05/07/2020
Caleb B.
United States United States
I recommend this product
  • Value for Money: Low ValueOK ValueGood ValueGreat ValueSuper Value
Excellent!

Was looking for a new Bay Rum and my beloved Dominica was sold out. I’m glad it was! This is a fantastic bay rum that is both aromatic AND balanced. Too many bay rums can just be clove aftershave, but this has some complexity to it and some staying power. Highly recommend.

KS
03/02/2020
Kirill S.
United States United States
I recommend this product
  • Value for Money: Low ValueOK ValueGood ValueGreat ValueSuper Value
Don't Judge A Book By Its Cover

By far the best aftershave in my 28-year wet shaving history. Back in the dark epoch of Gillette cartridge, I had a soft spot for trying various designer brand aftershaves. Now, an avid DE shaver, I have a soft spot for collecting "classic" aftershaves. Glad I ran into Captain's Choice Bay Rum, because it practically ended my obsessive search for the "perfect" aftershave. It's ironic that CC Bay Rum smells nearly awfully at the mouth of its bottle, at least to me. And it also comes in a bland, cough medicine-like, lame looking bottle and sticker. The only reason I purchased it was due to the stellar reviews on WCS site. .... And those reviews didn't disappoint. As soon as the "initial" burn subsides, you are treated to the most spectacular scent of bay rum and spice, and silky smooth, cooling coating on the skin, even after a rough shave. The scent will easily last for 3-4 hours. If I had to chose only one aftershave for the rest of my life, it would easily by Captain's Choice Bay Rum. Please keep this product going; otherwise, I will have to purchase at least 50 bottles of it.

M
02/22/2020
Mike
United States United States
I recommend this product
  • Value for Money: Low ValueOK ValueGood ValueGreat ValueSuper Value
Bay Rum Without Cloves is Not Bay Rum

It's a nice scent but missing that traditional bay rum aroma. However, if you dislike clove then this might be the bay rum for you. I'll use up my bottle and go back to my favorite bay rum.

JR
01/15/2020
John R.
United States United States
I recommend this product
  • Value for Money: Low ValueOK ValueGood ValueGreat ValueSuper Value
After Shave Splash

When you first splash on this after shave you begin to think that maybe you used too much. Give it ten seconds. It mellows out to a very pleasing Bay Rum scent. I have used other Bay Rums and I would have to say that this one could be my favorite. I will be able to judge it better after a few more uses.

MB
01/05/2020
Michael B.
United States United States
I recommend this product
Makes you wanna sing

"I'm a man, yes I am..." very manly scent. Not overpowering, doesn't make you reek and fill a room with your 'perfume' like young boys. It does all that it is advertised to do and smells great.