Skip to content
New Batch Of WCS Infinity Shaving Brushes Now Available!
New Batch Of WCS Infinity Shaving Brushes Now Available!

Captain's Choice After Shave Splash

71 reviews
Color: Bay Rum
  • Alcohol-based aftershave splash
  • Also available in a matching aftershave balms & shaving soaps
  • Choose your scent from the dropdown menu

Since 2011, the Captain has been crafting wet shaving goods to a loyal following. Using simple, tested, traditional recipes, he is producing shaving goods that keep people coming back for more.

This traditional aftershave splash is what put Captain’s Choice on the map. Just a few simple ingredients and phenomenal scent launched him into the wet shaving stardom. This alcohol-based splash is just what you need to tone, tighten, cleanse. It is packaged in an amber bottle with a classy nautical label. Under the screw top lid is a dispenser insert to make sure that your splash isn't a flood. The natural ingredients may settle over time, so give it a good shake before use.

  • Bay Rum: Captain's Choice Aftershave is the Bay Rum that has changed the mind of many a hater. It is a full-bodied bay rum with hints of cinnamon and citrus. For those of you who find the cloves overbearing in many bay rums, this is the bay rum for you! Not only does it smell great, it is also a very nice post shave treatment that will keep you feeling fresh and moisturized all day.
  • Cat O' Nine Tails: Named after the feared whip, cat o'nine tails, used to discipline sailors in time gone by, this aftershave might be the only time you look forward to "the tail". While similar to the original Captain's Choice Bay Rum aftershave, the Cat O' Nine Tails is unique with a significant burn. Some describe it as a "perfect burn". Splash it on after your shave and you will begin to notice a warming sensation that builds to a sensational heat. If you love to "feel the burn", you will love this splash. It is also scented with the Captain's take on bay rum. This one is a little darker and more mysterious than his original, but still with no clove.
  • Land ho! is Captain’s Choice newest aroma. This bright, light fougere will put a smile on your face - almost as wide a catching sight of land after months at sea. It has a citrus top note that blends into a soothing lavender. A lovely, refreshing scent.
  • Lime: This is a very pure lime fragrance and unlike most lime scents, it has decent staying power. While the scent isn't overpowering, it will stick with you and get you appreciative glances all day.
  • Sandalwood: Get the refreshing sensation with every application, and entice your (as well as others') senses with the sweet and rich sandalwood aroma with a gentle one-note scent (rather than a prominent multidimensional one, like most sandalwood on the market). This popular product will absolutely provide you the soothing comfort after your face is grazed by the sharp razor.
  • Venture: Nothing ventured, nothing gained. And with this scent. . . it is all gain. This head-turning, swoon worthy scent is a cheerful combination of citrus and pineapple with a foundation of bergamot and jasmine. Refreshing!

Size: 4 fl.oz

Ingredients:  Alcohol, fragrance oils, essential oils and extracts, glycerin. 

SHIPPING RESTRICTIONS: This product contains alcohol, which is potentially hazardous for shipping. We cannot ship it outside of the contiguous USA. If you are an international customer, this item will be refunded and will not be shipped. If you are a customer in the contiguous USA, your order will ship via ground regardless of the delivery option selected.
Customer Reviews
4.4 Based on 71 Reviews
Write a Review Ask a Question
  • Reviews
  • Questions

Thank you for submitting a review!

Your input is very much appreciated. Share it with your friends so they can enjoy it too!

Filter Reviews:
William H.
United States United States
I recommend this product
  • Value for Money: Low ValueOK ValueGood ValueGreat ValueSuper Value
they call me, ‘****** kid!’

i like bay rum after shave. put it in an atomizer & the bottle lasts a year.

Lloyd D.
United States United States
I recommend this product
  • Value for Money: Low ValueOK ValueGood ValueGreat ValueSuper Value
Great Stuff

My wife loves it. Soothing, no bite of alcohol. Smells great and it lasts. Been using it for ten years.

Ryan K.
United States United States
Mild but good

I really like this. Not quite as much burn as idlike, but still a tingle, and scent is good and mild.

A West Coast Shaving Customer
Matthew B.
United States United States
A must-try bay rum

The bay rum is a classic scent, and this is probably my favorite of all the bay rums I've tried. As with all the Captain's Choice aftershaves, it is top notch! The only problem is that the scent fades too fast! Captain, we're waiting on the cologne version... :)

Todd S.
United States United States
  • Value for Money: Low ValueOK ValueGood ValueGreat ValueSuper Value
a great aftershave

Captain's Choice is definitely worth your consideration as a formidable aftershave amid the plethora of aftershaves on the market today. It really does a healing work on my face. Admittedly, I'm not the world's biggest bay rum fan, but this one is really nice. I likely will not use it as a daily driver, but when I reach for it, I'll be rewarded with a superb finish to my shave and a pleasant aroma as well. Get yours today from the fine folks at West Coast Shaving.