Captain's Choice Shaving Soap | West Coast Shaving Skip to content
12 Days of Christmas Daily Deals! Day 7: $15 WCS Aftershaves Splashes
12 Days of Christmas Daily Deals! Day 7: $15 WCS Aftershaves Splashes

Captain's Choice Shaving Soap

13 reviews |
Save 30% Save 30%
Original price $21.99
Original price $21.99 - Original price $21.99
Original price $21.99
Current price $15.39
$15.39 - $15.39
Current price $15.39
  • Rich, luxurious, lasting lather
  • Veggie-based, non-tallow
  • Choose your scent from the dropdown menu

Captain's Choice has grown their brand slowly, introducing products only after extensive product testing. That means that when they released their shaving soap it was to rave reviews. Using their bespoke aftershave fragrances in a line of shaving soaps has wet shavers everywhere rejoicing.

Packed with vegetable glycerin and coconut oil, this grooming essential produces voluminous lather: rich, cushioning, creamy. And the lather lasts and lasts. . . Get the glide that you want for a close shave. You get 5 oz of amazing soap packaged in an 8 oz tub so that when you load up that frothy lather none of it escapes. Isn't that thoughtful?!?

But for many, the biggest selling point are the fragrances.

  • Bay Rum: This soap is scented with the same proprietary concentrate that is used in the popular Bay Rum aftershave that started it all. The "just there" aroma gives an enjoyable shave without being overpowering. This authentic scent has notes of cinnamon and citrus, but no cloves.
  • Lime: This scent is what loyal fans have been waiting for. This lime scent is so real that only rubbing the actual fruit on your face could be more authentic. The scent isn't overpowering, just a subtle pick-me-up as you whisk away the stubble. The gentler approach of this aroma reminds one of lazy days on a tropical beach, umbrella drink in hand.
  • Sandalwood: The aroma is designed to be "just there", not overwhelming or prominent. There is a little bit of zest in the top note but it is mostly a gentle, lingering aroma of true sandalwood. This fragrance will subtly attract those around you.

Make Captain's Choice, your choice!

Size: 5oz.

Made in the USA

Ingredients: Sodium Coco-Sulfate, Sodium Stearate, Cocomide MEA, Stearic Acid, Water (Aqua), Cetyl Alcohol, Mineral Oil, Fragrance, Isostearamidopropyl Morpholine Lactate, Triethanolamine

Customer Reviews
4.6 Based on 13 Reviews
5 ★
4 ★
3 ★
2 ★
1 ★
Write a Review Ask a Question

Thank you for submitting a review!

Your input is very much appreciated. Share it with your friends so they can enjoy it too!

Filter Reviews:
  • Captain
  • Lime
  • anything
  • choice
  • smell
  • soaps
  • purchase
  • shave
  • lather
Paul I.
  • Value for Money

Like This Soap

I have been surprised by the quality of these shaving soaps. I like the scents because they are masculine but not overpowering. Easy to work up a good lather.

Doug B.
  • Value for Money

Amazing smell!

Smell is great! Easy to lather, slick, shaves great. And I'm a novice only wet shaving for one year.

Doyle B.
  • Value for Money

Wonderful soap!

I thoroughly enjoy the scent and shaveability of this soap. I find I get good thick lather, with a good soothing feel.

David L.
  • Value for Money


It makes the blade slide smoothly, smells great, I just didn't realize it wasn't a hard bar of soap. I am concerned that it won't last as long as a bar will, but it seems to work better than the bar I had so far!

Jesse V.
  • Value for Money

A great product. Great smell,

A great product. Great smell, feel and texture for a great price.