Skip to content
Stainless Steel Safety Razors By Karve Now Available!
Stainless Steel Safety Razors By Karve Now Available!

Captain's Choice Cat O' Nine Tails Aftershave

35 reviews
  • Aftershave with "character" from Captain's Choice
  • With soothing witch hazel and moisturizing glycerin, and an added something extra for heat
  • Scented with bay rum

In 2011, the Captain exploded on the scene with his Captain's Choice Bay Rum. Introduced to enthusiastic reviews, the classic splash garnered much praise for its scent as well as its moisturizing properties. Well, the Captain is at it again and this time brings us a bay rum with serious burn. If you are looking for an aftershave with some "character", try out Captain's Choice Cat O' Nine Tails Aftershave.

Named after the feared whip, cat o'nine tails, used to discipline sailors in time gone by, this aftershave might be the only time you look forward to "the tail". While similar to the original Captain's Choice Bay Rum aftershave, the Cat O' Nine Tails is unique with a significant burn. Some describe it as a "perfect burn". Splash it on after your shave and you will begin to notice a warming sensation that builds to a sensational heat. If you love to "feel the burn", you will love this splash.

It is also scented with the Captain's take on bay rum. This one is a little darker and more mysterious than his original, but still with no clove. Said one reviewer, "The combination of scent and sensation is unmatched. I love this stuff because of the slow, rising heat that subsides just before it gets too hot, and then fades away so that only the singular scent remains. Perfect-o, Captain!"

Are you man enough to face it? Try Captain's Choice Cat O' Nine Tails Aftershave.

Size: 4oz

Ingredients: Alcohol, witch hazel, essential oils and extracts, glycerin

Made in the USA

SHIPPING RESTRICTIONS: This product contains alcohol, which is potentially hazardous for shipping. We cannot ship it outside of the contiguous USA. If you are an international customer, this item will be refunded and will not be shipped. If you are a customer in the contiguous USA, your order will ship via ground regardless of the delivery option selected.

Customer Reviews
4.4 Based on 35 Reviews
Write a Review Ask a Question
  • Reviews
  • Questions

Thank you for submitting a review!

Your input is very much appreciated. Share it with your friends so they can enjoy it too!

Filter Reviews:
  • scent
  • aftershave
  • something
  • choice
  • fragrance
  • bay rum
  • skin
  • burn
  • nine
  • captains
Allen M.
Canada Canada
I recommend this product
  • Value for Money: Low ValueOK ValueGood ValueGreat ValueSuper Value
Great products

Expensive but I like the brisk pinch of the astringent and like the fragrance.

Patrick C.
United States United States
Nice Warm Bay Rum

Co9T is my favorite Bay Rum. The Captains great scent with a little something to increase the burn a little. I just wish it lasted longer.

Dr. Joe
  • Value for Money: Low ValueOK ValueGood ValueGreat ValueSuper Value
An Excellent Aftershave

I found the captains Choice, Cat O ' Nine tails to be a very pleasant and robust aftershave. It has a pleasant, manly aroma that does not overpower but lasts quite a while. It braces the skin and gives what I found to be a good but not to strong after burn. I would recommend any man to give it a try and see what you think.

Cody H.
*** PANTHER!!!!

Get it. It will make you love shaving, again!

Dylan P.
  • Value for Money
Loooove WCS but I do not love this aftershave at all

So seriously, I think WCS is one of the coolest companies around and the absolute top of the market when it comes to wet shaving, but I have to warn you about this aftershave. The description say no clove, but as soon as I walked out of the bathroom after shaving, guess what my wife says... "Did you put something on with clove in it?" and cat o nine tails is a big overstatement too. I did a three pass shave with a few day old Feather blade and promptly applied this, and there was zero burn. Maybe i just got a perfect shave with no irritation, but seriously zero burn at all. Clubman or Brut burns 10X this product. I will give it some credit though; it does seem like a good quality, nourishing aftershave. This is unfortunate because I might have liked to try some other Captains Choice products but now I probably won't. Not a problem though, still lots of other fun stuff to try on here! I know this has high ratings from everyone else, so maybe its just me...