Skip to content
Buy One Aftershave, Get One Aftershave 20% Off. Use Code: BOGO20
Buy One Aftershave, Get One Aftershave 20% Off. Use Code: BOGO20

Captain's Choice

Captain's Choice is a brand that got started in the quest of the perfect aftershave. After smelling everything on the self at the local store, he set out to make his own. The owner is passionate about finding not only a great base for his products, but making sure it does the job it's supposed to do. So, his aftershaves close the pores and provide needed moisture, and his soaps clean well and smell great. The feedback and desires of customers is carefully considered when the final touches are made on these products. Just check out those customer reviews. We share his enthusiasm for all things that smell lovely and have even had the privilege of working along side of the Captain on a new product release: North. In pursuit of perfect, North went through dozens of revisions and review from two focus groups. Good enough, wasn't. It had to be great. His nautical labeling and packaging is brilliant and worthy of any fine shop or boutique (like ours). Our hats are off to The Captain!

  • Captain's Choice Cat O' Nine Tails Aftershave-West Coast Shaving
    $20.99

    Captain's Choice Cat O' Nine Tails Aftershave

    36 reviews

    Aftershave with "character" from Captain's Choice With soothing witch hazel and moisturizing glycerin, and an added something extra for heat Scent...

    View full details
    $20.99
  • Captain's Choice After Shave Splash, Eucalyptus-West Coast Shaving
    $20.99

    Captain's Choice After Shave Splash, Eucalyptus

    Alcohol-based aftershave splash Also available in a matching shaving soap Scented with refreshing eucalyptus aroma The Captain has been making ar...

    View full details
    $20.99
  • Captain's Choice Shaving Soap, Eucalyptus-West Coast Shaving
    $18.99

    Captain's Choice Shaving Soap, Eucalyptus

    Artisan shaving soap from Captain's Choice Glycerin and coconut oil provide glide and moisture Scented with a citrus aroma Well-loved artisan, Ca...

    View full details
    $18.99
  • Captain Choice Lather Bowl-Cobalt-West Coast Shaving
    from $39.99

    Captain Choice Lather Bowl

    3 reviews

    Bowl for creating a lather Handcrafted pottery Choose from blue sky, cobalt, gunmetal, rawhide, copper-heavyweight, and Scuttle Starry Night In 2...

    View full details
    from $39.99
  • Captain's Choice Shaving Soap, Land Ho!-West Coast Shaving
    $18.99

    Captain's Choice Shaving Soap, Land Ho!

    Vegan-based, lathering shaving soap Scented with a bright, light fougere Also available in an aftershave splash & aftershave balm Quality, s...

    View full details
    $18.99
  • Captain's Choice After Shave Splash-Bay Rum-West Coast Shaving
    $20.99

    Captain's Choice After Shave Splash

    75 reviews

    Alcohol-based aftershave splash Also available in a matching aftershave balms & shaving soaps Choose your scent from the dropdown menu Since ...

    View full details
    $20.99
  • Captain's Choice After Shave Splash, Land Ho!-West Coast Shaving
    $20.99

    Captain's Choice After Shave Splash, Land Ho!

    Alcohol-based aftershave splash Scented with a light fougere Also available in a matching aftershave balm & shaving soap Since 2011, the Ca...

    View full details
    $20.99
  • Captain's Choice Venture Aftershave-West Coast Shaving
    $20.99

    Captain's Choice Venture Aftershave

    2 reviews

    Alcohol-based aftershave splash Also available in a matching aftershave balms & shaving soaps Scented with pineapple, bergamot, and jasmine C...

    View full details
    $20.99
  • Captain's Choice Shaving Soap, Nor'easter-West Coast Shaving
    $18.99

    Captain's Choice Shaving Soap, Nor'easter

    3 reviews

    Artisan shaving soap from Captain's Choice Glycerin and coconut oil provide glide and moisture Scented with menthol and a masculine base note Y...

    View full details
    $18.99
  • Captain's Choice After Shave Splash, Island Time-West Coast Shaving
    $20.99

    Captain's Choice After Shave Splash, Island Time

    1 review

    Alcohol-based aftershave splash Also available in a matching aftershave balms & shaving soaps Scented with a tropical vacay aroma Captain’s C...

    View full details
    $20.99